Latest Developments

 

10/04/2012 Back To List
Late Winter Freeze in East Jerusalem turns to Spring Thaw

Quiet Freeze during the First Quarter of 2012
 
On January 3rd the Israel Lands Authority published the first 631 tenders of the 1557 punitive settlement units announced after the UNESCO vote. The timing was unfortunate (and almost certainly not coincidental) –  the units were announced the same day the Prime Minister’s envoy was conducting talks with Palestinian Authority negotiator Saeb Erekat in Amman.
 
From that date until April 4, 2012, no new tenders were published, including any of the remaining 926 units that were announced post-UNESCO.  In addition, during this period no new plans for settlement homes were deposited for public review, no plans approved, and no hearings on plans conducted.  It is unlikely that this happened by chance.  Rather, it appears that for the first quarter of 2012, there was a silent (and, notably, only partial) settlement freeze in East Jerusalem.  Partial, in that it did not apply to settler schemes in the Old City basin, like the Givati parking lot, or to non-residential schemes like the Refaim Park and Mount Scopus Slopes park. 
 
There are a number of possible reasons why Netanyahu may have decided to cool the ongoing East Jerusalem settlement surge during the first quarter of 2012.  The less likely possibilities are that Netanyahu has undergone a change of heart on settlements or is responding to international pressure.  We deem both of these explanations implausible, given Netanyahu’s history, his continued public stances, his previous readiness to ignore pressure from the U.S. and others in the international community, and in general, the absence of any confirming indications.  Moreover, the reality is that there appears that for now there is no real pressure, public or private, from the United States on Netanyahu over Jerusalem-related settlement issues.
 
The more likely explanation is that Netanyahu didn’t want to get blamed – by the Israeli people, the Obama Administration, the American Jewish community, or anyone else – for a collapse of the not-quite-dead-yet Israeli-Palestinian talks.   He also didn’t want to antagonize the Jordanians, both with respect to undermining Jordan-backed talks and to challenging Jordanian equities in Jerusalem.  This explanation is even more compelling viewed in the context of Netanyahu working assiduously to bring the Administration in Washington around to his way of thinking on, and dealing with, Iran.
 
In this context, it was apparent that this semi-freeze would not last much beyond the end of the first quarter of the year, for a number of reasons.  
 
·       Israeli-Palestinian peace talks are already nearly dead, so Netanyahu has little to fear in terms of being blamed if a Jerusalem settlement announcement becomes yet another nail in their already well-sealed coffin.
 
·       Israeli insiders in the media are increasingly convinced, it seems, that following Netanyahu’s Washington visit, military action against Iran is off the table for the immediate future, in large part because the Obama Administration won’t support it.  With the Obama Administration investing all of its Israel-related political capital in keeping Israel from forcing the issue, it seems likely that Netanyahu will judge – probably accurately – that there will be little or no cost (from the United States) to him going ahead with settlement projects.
 
·       Increasing Palestinian frustrations are giving birth to actions, like protests around Land Day and Jerusalem Day, that provide Netanyahu rationale to use Jerusalem settlement schemes to show the Palestinians and their supporters around the world who’s boss.  Any terrorist attack will provide similar rationale.
 
·       The smell of upcoming Israeli elections will likely whet Netanyahu’s appetite for new settlement actions that he can sell to hard-line constituencies.  
 
The Freeze Thaws – and the Settlement Floodgates Re-Open
 
On April 4, 2012, the Israel Lands Authority (ILA) and the Ministry of Construction published four tenders for 72 units in Har Homa B (one tender for 22 units and a second for 50 units, both within Town Plan 7509).  The ILA also published a tender for 4 commercial buildings in Har Homa B (Town Plan 7509). (All the tenders are dated April 3rd, but were published on April 4th). 
 
On that same day, they also published tenders for 800 units in Har Homa C (one tender for 632 units and a second tender for 168 units, both as part of Town Plan 10310).   (These tenders are also dated April 3rd, but were published on April 4th). 
 
This means that in a single day, the government of Israel issued tenders for the construction of 872 new East Jerusalem settlement units (plus 4 commercial buildings) – representing a 1.7% increase in the total number of units built in East Jerusalem settlements since 1967. 
 
All of these tenders are significant, but the Har Homa C tenders are especially so, given that this will be the first construction in Har Homa C.  As we have written previously, the Har Homa C plan involves construction that is, in it entirety, beyond the existing built-up area of the Har Homa settlement, significantly expanding the footprint of the settlement into a new area in the direction of Bethlehem/Beit Sahour.  In doing so, this construction will make a permanent status agreement on Jerusalem incrementally more difficult.   For more on this, see this analysis from Peace Now’s Hagit Ofran.  A map showing the Har Homa C construction can be viewed/downloaded here.
 
All of these tenders were in the pipeline and the government had previously announced that this construction would be expedited (for our earlier reporting on this see here).  As a result, the government may try to claim that there is no “news” here – that what happened on April 4th was just normal progression of construction that was approved in the past.  This is only partially correct, since the current tenders go beyond those “announced” informally in November. Regardless, the fact is that the government of Israel has the authority to prevent these plans from moving if it so chooses – and by the same token, publication of tenders indicates an affirmative decision of the government to go ahead with this new settlement construction.  The 800 units planned for Har Homa C are a case in point: the statutory approval process for those units received final approval on August 7, 2011, and tenders could have been issued at any point since that time.
 
The fact that it did not take place until now indicates that the government of Israel views the timing of publication of tenders as a political tool to be wielded for specific purposes at times of its choosing.  The decision to end the freeze – like the decision to impose it in the first place – did not happen by chance.  It comes in the context, rather, of what may well be an Israeli government perception that the U.S. and the international community will not pressure it (in part due to Iran talks that are about to begin), and a conscious desire to undermine ongoing diplomatic efforts to resume Israeli-Palestinian talks and ensure that the anticipated Abbas letter to Netanyahu is constructive in tone.
 
Consequently, both the statutory approval of the plans and the commencement of implementation of the plans (by means of these new tenders) are in integral part of the current, non-routine settlement surge we have noted in recent months.
 
Finally, as we have also noted previously, the fact that Israel is fast-tracking construction in Har Homa at all in particularly provocative  Har Homa is a settlement that was established by Netanyahu (in his previous term as prime minister) post-Oslo, over the strenuous objections of the Palestinians and the international community.  It has been a sticking point in previous negotiations and will be perceived as a deliberate provocation by the Palestinians, who have come to view Har Homa as the “flagship” of Israeli unilateral actions in East Jerusalem.
 
Comment
 
The fact that the freeze during the first quarter of 2012 didn’t last doesn’t mean that the freeze itself wasn’t important.  True, it does not change our existing predictions regarding the timeline for the viability of the two-state solution, but just as we saw with the Jerusalem settlement freeze from March-November 2010 (also a partial freeze, for the same reasons as detailed above), the freeze during the first quarter of 2012 demonstrates unequivocally that Netanyahu can quietly freeze settlements in Jerusalem if he chooses to do so and that doing so does not bring down his government or even have a high political cost for him. 
 
At the same time, it is important to recognize that even had this semi-freeze continued, it could not in all probability have been leveraged, on its own, into a renewed political process.  Netanyahu believes (and may be correct) that he can only freeze settlements silently, and the Palestinians need it done publicly for it to give them political cover, especially given the partial nature of the freeze (e.g., a silent freeze on government projects gives them zero political cover when settlement activities in Silwan/City of David continue apace).

17/9/2014 East Jerusalem Clashes Continue

 


9/9/2014 East Jerusalem Aflame

 


4/9/2014 The Real Story about those new units "approved" for Palestinians in East Jerusalem

 


26/8/2014 Gilo Tenders Awarded, but (for now) EJ Settlement Freeze Continues

 


19/5/2014 Jerusalem Settlements - The (Proximate, Contributing) Cause of the Collapse

 


19/5/2014 Post-Collapse - De Facto Freeze in East Jerusalem, But the Lull Won’t Last

 


19/5/2014 Are We Sliding Toward Religious War? A Brief Survey of Key Jerusalem Developments/Trends

 


5/3/2014 Framework Language and Jerusalem: Gimmicks Are NOT the Answer

 


5/3/2014 New Israeli Yeshiva Approved...in Downtown Sheikh Jarrah

 


5/3/2014 Playing with Fire, Part 2: Elad Set to Gain Control of Area Adjacent to the Temple Mt/Haram al Sharif

 


5/3/2014 Playing with Fire, Part 1: Debating the Status Quo on the Temple Mount

 


3/3/2014 Demolition orders in E-1

 


9/1/2014 New Seidemann Op-Ed in the Guardian: The myth of an undivided Jerusalem is collapsing under its own weight

 


12/12/2013 Danny Seidemann Injured by Stone-Thrower - Condition Update & Comment

 


12/12/2013 East Jerusalem Settlements since the Resumption of Talks: the Facts & their Implications

 


12/12/2013 The [Apparent] Re-Emergence of the “Greater Jerusalem” Gimmick

 


12/12/2013 Post-Script: Those Planning Tenders for 24,000 New Settlement Units

 


27/8/2013 Ramat Shlomo Back in the Headlines

 


27/8/2013 Funding Approved for Settler-Run Projects in Silwan and Jebel Mukabber

 


27/8/2013 Three Palestinians Killed by Israeli Forces in Qalandia RC

 


27/8/2013 ?Uptick in East Jerusalem Home Demolitions

 


19/8/2013 Pyromaniacs Target the Temple Mount

 


19/8/2013 Jerusalem Residency Concerns Resurface

 


19/8/2013 New Pro-Settlement Guidelines on Absentee Property Law

 


19/8/2013 A U.S. Court Rules on Jerusalem

 


16/8/2013 Timeline/details of Recent Jerusalem-Related Settlement Developments

 


16/8/2013 Bibi, Settlements & Peace Talks -- Analysis

 


13/6/2013 The A-Zayyem/Mount of Olives Interchange, Plan 14049

 


13/6/2013 Tenders Awarded for Ramot Expansion, Additional Tenders for Mordot Gilo

 


13/6/2013 Everything You Need to Know About Jerusalem & the Absentee Property Law

 


7/5/2013 The IDF Colleges on the Mt. of Olives Off the Agenda, Again

 


7/5/2013 Plans Published for Old City Cable Car

 


7/5/2013 Sharansky Plan Hits a Wall, no pun intended

 


7/5/2013 The Wall/Barrier vs. Cremisan & Beit Jala

 


5/5/2013 Spatial Shaping in J'lem Continues with Opening of Route 20

 


24/4/2013 Concerns about Proposed “Solution” to Women’s Prayer Issue at the Western Wall

 


22/4/2013 The Politics of Waste Treatment in East Jerusalem

 


15/4/2013 Fifty New Units in East Talpiot

 


14/1/2013 E-1/Bab ash-Shams: What Happened, What it Means, What Next

 


28/12/2012 Mordot Gilo South - APPROVED

 


19/12/2012 Givat Hamatos APPROVED - What it Means

 


17/12/2012 Breaking News - Approvals this week - Ramat Shlomo & Givat Hamatos

 


5/12/2012 The E-1 Crisis...This Is Not a Drill

 


6/11/2012 More than 1200 New Tenders Issued for Pisgat Ze'ev and Ramot

 


31/10/2012 New Construction Approved in Har Homa

 


30/10/2012 New East Jerusalem Settlement Construction Approved - East Talpiot units for Israeli Security Personnel

 


24/10/2012 Mordot Gilo Construction Approved

 


24/10/2012 Plans for IDF Colleges on Mt. of Olives Deposited for Public Review & Explanation of Location

 


24/10/2012 Taking the Garbage to East Jerusalem

 


24/10/2012 Is the Palestinian Population of East Jerusalem Becoming More Israeli -- No

 


24/10/2012 Pisgat Zeev in the News

 


18/10/2012 Crisis Brewing on the Temple Mount

 


17/9/2012 Jerusalem, Netanyahu and the two-state solution

 


16/9/2012 Issue to watch: East Jerusalem Home Demolitions

 


16/9/2012 Attacks on Palestinians in Jerusalem – Sign of the “Hebronization” of the City

 


16/9/2012 Jerusalem in the Headlines: Ras al-Amud, Temple Mount, the Barrier, Elad, & Har Homa

 


15/9/2012 Jerusalem: Political Football in U.S. Presidential Race

 


14/9/2012 In Memorium: Our Friend, Chris Stevens

 


2/7/2012 New Tenders Published for East Jerusalem Settlement Construction

 


2/7/2012 Plans for New IDF War College on the Mt. of Olives Approved for Public Review

 


8/5/2012 Arab VIPs Start Coming to Jerusalem

 


7/5/2012 Givat Hamatos – Nearing the Point-of-No-Return

 


7/5/2012 IDF College on the Mt. of Olives – Moving Forward

 


7/5/2012 Kidmat Tzion – Municipal Approval Anticipated Soon

 


7/5/2012 Mughrabi Ramp – Some Good News

 


6/5/2012 Beit Hanina Settlement Effort Continues

 


10/4/2012 Late Winter Freeze in East Jerusalem turns to Spring Thaw

 


8/4/2012 Kidmat Tziyon Settlement Scheme to be Expedited

 


8/4/2012 New East Jerusalem “Park” Soon to get Final Approval

 


8/4/2012 New Settlement in Beit Hanina?

 


8/4/2012 Israeli High Court Rejects Shepherd’s Hotel Appeal

 


14/3/2012 Will Arab & Muslim Leaders Start Coming to Jerusalem?


 


14/3/2012 A Major East Jerusalem Settlement Plan Comes Back to Life

 


14/3/2012 Spotlight on Jewish Access to the Temple Mount

 


14/3/2012 Volatility in Silwan: Mini-Intifada Continues, Cave-Ins, and New Settler Plans

 


9/1/2012 The Ongoing Settlement Surge in East Jerusalem

 


9/1/2012 The Mughrabi Gate Saga - Update

 


10/12/2011 Barkat Tries to Force Mughrabi Ramp Demolition

 


9/12/2011 Approval of Mount Scopus "Park" Proceeds

 


13/10/2011 Approval for New Israeli Settlement at Givat Hamatos Proceeds

 


12/10/2011 New Pisgat Ze'ev Building Permits

 


28/9/2011 New Settlement Approval issued for Gilo - Plan 13261

 


11/8/2011 More Jerusalem Settlement Approvals: Ramat Shlomo, Pisgat Zeev, Givat Hamatos

 


10/8/2011 Yet Another Har Homa Plan Approved (No. 12825) - Public Buildings, 50 Units

 


5/8/2011 Har Homa C Plan 10310 (app. 983 units) Approved

 


9/7/2011 Jerusalem Municipal "Approval" of Mordot Gilo Plan

 


9/7/2011 Meretz Rejoins Municipal Coalition - Separate Portfolios for EJ Settlers and Palestinians

 


20/6/2011 The Ramat Shlomo House Extension Plans

 


10/6/2011 Committee for Acceleration of (EJ) Construction to Convene on June 14

 


24/5/2011 Netanyahu Approves East Jerusalem Construction Hours Before Obama Address

 


24/5/2011 Barkat Trying to Force Netanyahu's Hand on Mughrabi Ramp

 


12/5/2011 The Non-Existent Court Decision on Bustan Demolitions

 


10/5/2011 New East Jerusalem Settlements Update

 


9/5/2011 US Supreme Court to Hear Jerusalem Status Case

 


21/4/2011 Is There a De Facto Settlement Freeze in East Jerusalem? The Facts

 


18/4/2011 April Surge in East Jerusalem Construction Plans

 


18/4/2011 Mount Scopus Slopes Park Approved for Public Review

 


16/3/2011 Permit Issued for 14 Units at Ras el Amud Police Station

 


16/3/2011 Permit Issued for Mughrabi Ramp

 

29/7/2013 A Layman's Guide to Jerusalem House Demolitions
Daniel Seidemann

 


29/7/2013 A Laymen's Guide to the Planning Process in Jerusalem.pdf
Daniel Seidmann

 


20/3/2013 "Spatial Shaping", the Ross Agenda and a Partial Settlement Freeze
Daniel Seidmann

 


10/3/2013 Spatial Shaping - Unilaterally Determining Israel’s Base-Line Border
Daniel Seidmann

 


10/9/2012 NOREF Policy Brief August 2012 | By Daniel Seidemann
Daniel Seidemann

 


30/1/2012 East Jerusalem and the Imminent Demise of the Two-State Solution
Daniel Seidemann

 


7/11/2011 East Jerusalem Developments and Trends: 2006-2011
Daniel Seidemann

 


31/10/2011 The TJ Guide to the Planning and Construction Process in East Jerusalem - Oct. 2011
Daniel Seidemann

 


15/10/2011 Givat Hamatos/Mordot Gilo: New Settlement Schemes on Jerusalem's Southern Flank
Daniel Seidemann

 


12/8/2011 U.S. (non)-Recognition of Sovereignty in Jerusalem: A Consistent Policy, 1948 - 2011
Lara Friedman

 


1/8/2011 Hanging On By Our Fingernails
Daniel Seidemann

 


22/2/2011 Jerusalem Challenges the API
Daniel Seidemann

 


21/2/2011 East Jerusalem settlers and Israel's never-ending War of Independence
Daniel Seidemann

 


20/2/2011 The Two Jerusalems
D. Seidemann D.Rothem

 


19/2/2011 Jerusalem on the Brink
Daniel Seidemann

 


19/2/2011 A barely tolerated minority
Daniel Seidemann

 


17/2/2011 Redeeming Jerusalem by truth, not hollow slogans
Daniel Seidemann

 


16/2/2011 Jerusalem, settlements, and the "everybody knows" fallacy
Lara Friedman - Daniel Seidemann

 


15/2/2011 Blogposts
Lara Friedman
 
 
http://www.sayarch.com/