Latest Developments

 

11/08/2011 Back To List
More Jerusalem Settlement Approvals: Ramat Shlomo, Pisgat Zeev, Givat Hamatos

On August 11,  Minister of Interior Eli Yishai announced that he had granted final approval to three large settlement plans in East Jerusalem. According to a statement issued by Minister Yishai’s spokesperson, the three plans are:

 

Plan 11085, Ramat Shlomo (1600 Units)

Plan 11647, Pisgat Zeev (625 Units)

Plan 5834 A, Givat Hamatos, (2337 Units)

 

These approvals come on the heels of the August 7, 2011 approval of Har Homa C (Plan number 10310, for 983 units) and for construction in Har Homa B for public buildings and 50 units (Plan number 12825), discussed here and here.

 

All of these plans are initiated and backed by the government of Israel.

 

As today’s statement by the spokesman of the Ministry of Interior conveys, significant approvals for East Jerusalem settlement construction were granted today.  However, the press release contains information that is both incorrect and misleading.  

 

Specifically, with respect to the Ramat Shlomo approval, this plan legally cannot have received final approval from the Minister, since it was never actually published for public review after the March 2010 Biden visit (although during the visit it was decided to do so).  That said, today’s announcements clearly expedited settlement expansion in East Jerusalem, even if in a manner that differs with precisely what is being hyped by the Ministry of the Interior.

 

Likewise, the Givat Hamatos scheme has indeed received final approval, but this approval does not mean that tenders can be issued and permits granted.  Givat Hamatos is a complicated case, because the patterns of land ownership in the area – Israeli, Palestinian, and church – are dauntingly complicated.  Even with the final approval granted, the plan cannot be implemented until the land ownership issues are sorted out in a manner to permit construction, requiring another planning process called “reparcellation.”  Until then, no tenders can be issued or permits granted. The reparcellation schemes for Givat Hamatos are already before the Municipal Planning Committee, and their approval may be only months away but in the meantime, any approval granted by the Minister cannot be implemented. 

 

The numbers

 

In terms of numbers, in the space of less than one week Israeli has expedited the construction of 5595 settlement units in East Jerusalem.  This total represents an 11% increase in the total number of units built for Israelis in East Jerusalem since 1967.  This total is also 930% greater than all the units built with government support for Palestinians in East Jerusalem since 1967. Based on these latest approvals, we can anticipate in a matter of a few short weeks the publication of tenders for the construction of at least 1658 new units – a 3.3% increase in the number ofEast Jerusalem settlement units, and 276% more than all those units built for Palestinians with government support since 1967.

 

The impact on the ground

 

Givat Hamatos:  The Givat Hamatos plan – involving a “Balkanized” pattern of construction based on ethnic/national lines – would, if implemented, greatly complicate any future agreement on Jerusalem.  The area in question – wedged between the settlement of Gilo, theJerusalem (Palestinian) neighborhood of Beit Safafa, and the West Bank city of Bethlehem – is already potentially the most difficult place to delineate a viable border between Israel and Palestine.  If the Givat Hamatos plan is carried out, it will for all intents and purposes preclude Palestinian Beit Safafa ever becoming part of Palestine (making the implementation of the Clinton parameters or the an agreement along the lines of the  Geneva Initiative virtually impossible). The decision to move forward with the Givat Hamatos plan – a plan that municipal officials have admitted in the past poses truly daunting challenges from a legal/technical standpoint – sends a message that the Netanyahu government is determined to go after every square inch of land in East Jerusalem, even those areas where construction is least feasible. 

 

Har Homa C:  As we have discussed previously, the Har Homa C plan provides for a new section of Har Homa, involving construction that is, in its entirety, beyond the existing built-up area of the settlement.  It significantly expands the footprint of the settlement into a new area in the direction of Bethlehem/Beit Sahour (onto a hill that is currently covered in trees).  This plan changes the potential border between Israel and Palestine in Jerusalem more than any other East Jerusalem plan that has been approved in recent years, and will make a permanent status agreement on Jerusalem incrementally more difficult.  A map of the Har Homa B and C plans is available here.

 

Pisgat Zeev:  The Pisgat Zeev plan, if implemented, will “weld” the settlement to the Palestinian neighborhood of Beit Hanina, making the creation of a reasonable border regime in the area more difficult.

 

Ramat Shlomo:  The Ramat Shlomo plan will would almost double the size of the existing settlement. Given the history of this Ramat Shlomo plan (in particular its role in the high-profile dust-up between the Obama Administration and the Netanyahu government in March 2010), announcing final approval of the plan now (even if that announcement is misleading) is nothing short of a very public “F- You” statement by the Netanyahu government, aimed at both the Obama Administration and the Palestinians.   Back when this came up in March 2010, the Israeli Government gave assurances that the plan would be indefinitely “kicked down the road.”  However, when it comes to East Jerusalemsettlements, “indefinite” appears to be a very elastic term.


The political impact


With these approvals the Netanyahu government is telegraphing clear messages about its intentions with respect to 
Jerusalem, to the Palestinians (and the possibility of ever re-starting peace efforts), and to the Obama administration and the international community. So in East Jerusalem, the proverbial “September” that everyone has been girding for has come early, and the age of unilateralism is already well upon us.

 

In all likelihood there are also internal coalition politics at play.  There can be no question that it was Netanyahu himself who decided to open theEast Jeusalem settlement floodgates last November, allowing a surge in approvals to begin.  Since then he has periodically reined things in when it suited him and letting them go forward when he wanted to stick it to Obama, but for the most part he let things continue on their already careening course forward. 

 

With this recent spate of major approvals, it seems clear that Minister Yishai is hijacking Netanyahu’s new readiness to support settlement in construction in East Jerusalem – in effect, he is trying to be “out-Bibi Bibi.”  His motivations for doing so are multiple.  First, he is likely more than happy to rock the foundations of the coalition at a time when Netanyahu is under unprecedented domestic pressure (over the housing protests), in effect sending Netanyahu a message that on the one hand there is nothing he can do to assert control over events in Jerusalem, even if he wants to, and on the other, that it will be Yishai, not Netanyahu, who will demand credit from supporters of settlement expansion. Second, these approvals are a great way for Yishai to consolidate his own political base.  And third, they are a way for him to differentiate himself from Aryeh Deri, the aspiring once-and-future leader of the Shas party.

 

With Washington caught in the currents of economic crisis, two wars and political dysfunction, with Europe caught between defaults, rioting and the August vacation season  and the Middle East in turmoil, it seems that the timing and the choreography of this could not be better for better for the settler enterprise and the Netanyahu government which so vigorously supports it, and could not be worse for the prospects of peace and preserving the two-state solution in Jerusalem.


3/11/2014 Attempted Assassination Raises the Stakes at the Temple Mount

 


3/11/2014 Reasons Behind Escalating Temple Mount Crisis

 


3/11/2014 Bibi's New Settlement Initiative - Ramat Shlomo & Har Homa

 


3/11/2014 More Settler Takeovers in Another Part of Silwan

 


2/10/2014 Netanyahu Cannot Evade Responsibility for Givat Hamatos Approval & Silwan Takeovers

 


1/10/2014 Breaking & Urgent News: Givat Hamatos Approved

 


30/9/2014 Major Development: In Overnight Operation, Settlers Take Over Multiple Buildings in Silwan

 


18/9/2014 Specter of E-1 Raised by Plan to Relocate Bedouin

 


18/9/2014 Looming Crisis in East Jerusalem - Givat Hamatos

 


17/9/2014 East Jerusalem Clashes Continue

 


9/9/2014 East Jerusalem Aflame

 


4/9/2014 The Real Story about those new units "approved" for Palestinians in East Jerusalem

 


26/8/2014 Gilo Tenders Awarded, but (for now) EJ Settlement Freeze Continues

 


19/5/2014 Jerusalem Settlements - The (Proximate, Contributing) Cause of the Collapse

 


19/5/2014 Post-Collapse - De Facto Freeze in East Jerusalem, But the Lull Won’t Last

 


19/5/2014 Are We Sliding Toward Religious War? A Brief Survey of Key Jerusalem Developments/Trends

 


5/3/2014 Framework Language and Jerusalem: Gimmicks Are NOT the Answer

 


5/3/2014 New Israeli Yeshiva Approved...in Downtown Sheikh Jarrah

 


5/3/2014 Playing with Fire, Part 2: Elad Set to Gain Control of Area Adjacent to the Temple Mt/Haram al Sharif

 


5/3/2014 Playing with Fire, Part 1: Debating the Status Quo on the Temple Mount

 


3/3/2014 Demolition orders in E-1

 


9/1/2014 New Seidemann Op-Ed in the Guardian: The myth of an undivided Jerusalem is collapsing under its own weight

 


12/12/2013 Danny Seidemann Injured by Stone-Thrower - Condition Update & Comment

 


12/12/2013 East Jerusalem Settlements since the Resumption of Talks: the Facts & their Implications

 


12/12/2013 The [Apparent] Re-Emergence of the “Greater Jerusalem” Gimmick

 


12/12/2013 Post-Script: Those Planning Tenders for 24,000 New Settlement Units

 


27/8/2013 Ramat Shlomo Back in the Headlines

 


27/8/2013 Funding Approved for Settler-Run Projects in Silwan and Jebel Mukabber

 


27/8/2013 Three Palestinians Killed by Israeli Forces in Qalandia RC

 


27/8/2013 ?Uptick in East Jerusalem Home Demolitions

 


19/8/2013 Pyromaniacs Target the Temple Mount

 


19/8/2013 Jerusalem Residency Concerns Resurface

 


19/8/2013 New Pro-Settlement Guidelines on Absentee Property Law

 


19/8/2013 A U.S. Court Rules on Jerusalem

 


16/8/2013 Timeline/details of Recent Jerusalem-Related Settlement Developments

 


16/8/2013 Bibi, Settlements & Peace Talks -- Analysis

 


13/6/2013 The A-Zayyem/Mount of Olives Interchange, Plan 14049

 


13/6/2013 Tenders Awarded for Ramot Expansion, Additional Tenders for Mordot Gilo

 


13/6/2013 Everything You Need to Know About Jerusalem & the Absentee Property Law

 


7/5/2013 The IDF Colleges on the Mt. of Olives Off the Agenda, Again

 


7/5/2013 Plans Published for Old City Cable Car

 


7/5/2013 Sharansky Plan Hits a Wall, no pun intended

 


7/5/2013 The Wall/Barrier vs. Cremisan & Beit Jala

 


5/5/2013 Spatial Shaping in J'lem Continues with Opening of Route 20

 


24/4/2013 Concerns about Proposed “Solution” to Women’s Prayer Issue at the Western Wall

 


22/4/2013 The Politics of Waste Treatment in East Jerusalem

 


15/4/2013 Fifty New Units in East Talpiot

 


14/1/2013 E-1/Bab ash-Shams: What Happened, What it Means, What Next

 


28/12/2012 Mordot Gilo South - APPROVED

 


19/12/2012 Givat Hamatos APPROVED - What it Means

 


17/12/2012 Breaking News - Approvals this week - Ramat Shlomo & Givat Hamatos

 


5/12/2012 The E-1 Crisis...This Is Not a Drill

 


6/11/2012 More than 1200 New Tenders Issued for Pisgat Ze'ev and Ramot

 


31/10/2012 New Construction Approved in Har Homa

 


30/10/2012 New East Jerusalem Settlement Construction Approved - East Talpiot units for Israeli Security Personnel

 


24/10/2012 Mordot Gilo Construction Approved

 


24/10/2012 Plans for IDF Colleges on Mt. of Olives Deposited for Public Review & Explanation of Location

 


24/10/2012 Taking the Garbage to East Jerusalem

 


24/10/2012 Is the Palestinian Population of East Jerusalem Becoming More Israeli -- No

 


24/10/2012 Pisgat Zeev in the News

 


18/10/2012 Crisis Brewing on the Temple Mount

 


17/9/2012 Jerusalem, Netanyahu and the two-state solution

 


16/9/2012 Issue to watch: East Jerusalem Home Demolitions

 


16/9/2012 Attacks on Palestinians in Jerusalem – Sign of the “Hebronization” of the City

 


16/9/2012 Jerusalem in the Headlines: Ras al-Amud, Temple Mount, the Barrier, Elad, & Har Homa

 


15/9/2012 Jerusalem: Political Football in U.S. Presidential Race

 


14/9/2012 In Memorium: Our Friend, Chris Stevens

 


2/7/2012 New Tenders Published for East Jerusalem Settlement Construction

 


2/7/2012 Plans for New IDF War College on the Mt. of Olives Approved for Public Review

 


8/5/2012 Arab VIPs Start Coming to Jerusalem

 


7/5/2012 Givat Hamatos – Nearing the Point-of-No-Return

 


7/5/2012 IDF College on the Mt. of Olives – Moving Forward

 


7/5/2012 Kidmat Tzion – Municipal Approval Anticipated Soon

 


7/5/2012 Mughrabi Ramp – Some Good News

 


6/5/2012 Beit Hanina Settlement Effort Continues

 


10/4/2012 Late Winter Freeze in East Jerusalem turns to Spring Thaw

 


8/4/2012 Kidmat Tziyon Settlement Scheme to be Expedited

 


8/4/2012 New East Jerusalem “Park” Soon to get Final Approval

 


8/4/2012 New Settlement in Beit Hanina?

 


8/4/2012 Israeli High Court Rejects Shepherd’s Hotel Appeal

 


14/3/2012 Will Arab & Muslim Leaders Start Coming to Jerusalem?


 


14/3/2012 A Major East Jerusalem Settlement Plan Comes Back to Life

 


14/3/2012 Spotlight on Jewish Access to the Temple Mount

 


14/3/2012 Volatility in Silwan: Mini-Intifada Continues, Cave-Ins, and New Settler Plans

 


9/1/2012 The Ongoing Settlement Surge in East Jerusalem

 


9/1/2012 The Mughrabi Gate Saga - Update

 


10/12/2011 Barkat Tries to Force Mughrabi Ramp Demolition

 


9/12/2011 Approval of Mount Scopus "Park" Proceeds

 


13/10/2011 Approval for New Israeli Settlement at Givat Hamatos Proceeds

 


12/10/2011 New Pisgat Ze'ev Building Permits

 


28/9/2011 New Settlement Approval issued for Gilo - Plan 13261

 


11/8/2011 More Jerusalem Settlement Approvals: Ramat Shlomo, Pisgat Zeev, Givat Hamatos

 


10/8/2011 Yet Another Har Homa Plan Approved (No. 12825) - Public Buildings, 50 Units

 


5/8/2011 Har Homa C Plan 10310 (app. 983 units) Approved

 


9/7/2011 Jerusalem Municipal "Approval" of Mordot Gilo Plan

 


9/7/2011 Meretz Rejoins Municipal Coalition - Separate Portfolios for EJ Settlers and Palestinians

 


20/6/2011 The Ramat Shlomo House Extension Plans

 


10/6/2011 Committee for Acceleration of (EJ) Construction to Convene on June 14

 


24/5/2011 Netanyahu Approves East Jerusalem Construction Hours Before Obama Address

 


24/5/2011 Barkat Trying to Force Netanyahu's Hand on Mughrabi Ramp

 


12/5/2011 The Non-Existent Court Decision on Bustan Demolitions

 


10/5/2011 New East Jerusalem Settlements Update

 


9/5/2011 US Supreme Court to Hear Jerusalem Status Case

 


21/4/2011 Is There a De Facto Settlement Freeze in East Jerusalem? The Facts

 


18/4/2011 April Surge in East Jerusalem Construction Plans

 


18/4/2011 Mount Scopus Slopes Park Approved for Public Review

 


16/3/2011 Permit Issued for 14 Units at Ras el Amud Police Station

 


16/3/2011 Permit Issued for Mughrabi Ramp

 

29/7/2013 A Layman's Guide to Jerusalem House Demolitions
Daniel Seidemann

 


29/7/2013 A Laymen's Guide to the Planning Process in Jerusalem.pdf
Daniel Seidmann

 


20/3/2013 "Spatial Shaping", the Ross Agenda and a Partial Settlement Freeze
Daniel Seidmann

 


10/3/2013 Spatial Shaping - Unilaterally Determining Israel’s Base-Line Border
Daniel Seidmann

 


10/9/2012 NOREF Policy Brief August 2012 | By Daniel Seidemann
Daniel Seidemann

 


30/1/2012 East Jerusalem and the Imminent Demise of the Two-State Solution
Daniel Seidemann

 


7/11/2011 East Jerusalem Developments and Trends: 2006-2011
Daniel Seidemann

 


31/10/2011 The TJ Guide to the Planning and Construction Process in East Jerusalem - Oct. 2011
Daniel Seidemann

 


15/10/2011 Givat Hamatos/Mordot Gilo: New Settlement Schemes on Jerusalem's Southern Flank
Daniel Seidemann

 


12/8/2011 U.S. (non)-Recognition of Sovereignty in Jerusalem: A Consistent Policy, 1948 - 2011
Lara Friedman

 


1/8/2011 Hanging On By Our Fingernails
Daniel Seidemann

 


22/2/2011 Jerusalem Challenges the API
Daniel Seidemann

 


21/2/2011 East Jerusalem settlers and Israel's never-ending War of Independence
Daniel Seidemann

 


20/2/2011 The Two Jerusalems
D. Seidemann D.Rothem

 


19/2/2011 Jerusalem on the Brink
Daniel Seidemann

 


19/2/2011 A barely tolerated minority
Daniel Seidemann

 


17/2/2011 Redeeming Jerusalem by truth, not hollow slogans
Daniel Seidemann

 


16/2/2011 Jerusalem, settlements, and the "everybody knows" fallacy
Lara Friedman - Daniel Seidemann

 


15/2/2011 Blogposts
Lara Friedman
 
 
http://www.sayarch.com/